Save Pin
Everyone at my place waits all year for this eye-popping Patriotic Poke Cake when summer rolls around. Especially for the Fourth of July, the bold blue, red, and white stripes always steal the show. People cheer when you slice into it. The pudding layer is cool and creamy and it's a breeze to pull together—plus, you can make it ahead for get-togethers or backyard barbecues.
When I brought this to the neighborhood potluck, every last piece disappeared. Neighbors kept asking me to make it again for next year. Honestly, nothing beats how excited kids get poking holes and swirling the colors in this cake.
Vibrant Ingredients
- Sprinkles for garnish: Finish it off with some fun—try red, white, or blue for extra flair
- Red and blue food coloring: Get bright, happy colors—gel works best for boldness
- Vanilla extract: Adds cozy flavor—use real vanilla if you can
- Powdered sugar: Blends into the whipped cream—sift if it's clumpy
- Heavy cream: Whipping makes dreamy topping—full fat is easier to work with
- Milk: Makes the pudding set—whole milk gives a creamier texture
- Instant cheesecake pudding: Brings a tangy and smooth filling—cheesecake flavor is key for that hint of zip
- Eggs, water, and oil: Just use what's on the cake mix box—fresh eggs keep it light
- White cake mix: Starts everything off simple—go with a trusted brand for fluffier cake
Simple Step Guide
- Frost and Garnish:
- Finish strong—spread whipped cream on the chilly cake, then top with a generous scatter of sprinkles
- Whip the Cream:
- Chill your cream and start whipping with vanilla until soft peaks, then toss in powdered sugar and beat to stiff peaks
- Chill the Cake:
- Now slide the cake into the fridge. Wait until the pudding layer is set and cold
- Prepare the Pudding Layer:
- Beat together pudding mix with milk in a bowl, pour over the cooled cake before it sets, making sure it seeps into all those poked spots, then gently smooth the rest on top
- Poke the Cake:
- Give the fresh cake about ten minutes to cool then poke deep holes with the end of a wooden spoon. Let it cool all the way—this helps your pudding layer hold up
- Bake the Cake:
- Follow the cake mix box for time and temp, bake until a toothpick slides out clean from the middle
- Layer and Swirl:
- Randomly drop spoonfuls of colored batter into the pan, layering as you fill it up. Gently tap the dish to even things out and swirl with a toothpick until those fun streaks pop—don't go overboard so the colors don't muddy
- Mix and Divide the Batter:
- Mix your cake ingredients according to the box, then pour into three bowls—leave one white, and tint the others with blue and red. Make sure the colors are mixed in with no streaks
- Prep the Cake Pan:
- Coat a 9x13-inch dish thoroughly with baking spray so nothing sticks
Save Pin
Poke cake was always the star at my family’s July Fourth dinners when I was a kid. That’s one tradition I’m glad I kept going. I can’t get enough of how every slice has a different swirl and I always swipe extra whipped cream before I serve it up.
How to store it
Pop leftovers in the fridge covered up tight. It'll keep tasting good for three days, and the pudding keeps it from turning dry. For the best bite, let it sit out about fifteen minutes before you dig in.
Swap out ingredients
If you want to keep it simple, vanilla instant pudding works fine instead of cheesecake. Allergies? Try plant milk and dairy-free topping. No food coloring left? Smash up raspberries and blueberries for natural color; it won’t be as eye-catching but still looks great.
Ideas for serving
Cut thick slices and serve cold for a real treat. I love adding a pile of strawberries or blueberries on the side. It’s a real stunner if you ring the platter with sliced fruit and a shower of sprinkles for an extra festive look.
Save Pin
Fun facts and background
Poke cakes showed up in American kitchens around the 1950s, making bright-color cakes with pudding or Jello. They were everywhere at picnics and parties even before folks were posting everything online. It was an easy way to impress the crowd with color and flavor.
Common Questions
- → How do you get those super bright red and blue cake layers?
Scoop some food coloring into separate bowls of your cake batter and blend well before dropping into your pan. Pour them in layers and give them a slow swirl so the colors don’t mix too much.
- → Why poke holes in the cake after baking?
Making holes lets the pudding get way down inside, so the cake turns out soft and full of flavor in every bite.
- → Can I make this using my own homemade cake instead of a box?
For sure. Mix up your best white cake from scratch, then split and color the batter just like you would with the box mix.
- → How early can I pull this together ahead of time?
Go ahead and prep it the night before. Once the pudding and cream are on, stash the cake in the fridge to keep it nice and fresh.
- → What's the best way to keep leftovers?
Cover and keep extra cake in the fridge. It'll taste fresh and moist for about three days.
- → Can I try out different colors for other events?
Yes, totally! Use other food colors to match whatever holiday you're celebrating, like green and red for Christmas, or orange with black for Halloween.