Filet Mignon with Shrimp Lobster

The first time I tried pairing filet mignon with a rich seafood sauce was during a holiday feast when a dear friend brought along lobster tail and shrimp, insisting I try a surf-and-turf twist. The way the tender steak soaked up the creamy garlic sauce studded with sweet lobster and shrimp was unforgettable—a dish that instantly felt both indulgent and special enough to make any occasion memorable.

I remember the first time I knocked this together on a tight timeline and was amazed that such simple steps could deliver layers of flavor. The seafood sauce turned out silky and luxurious, perfectly complementing the beef, and it was a turning point for me in marrying surf and turf at home.

Essential Ingredients

• Filet Mignon: tender, lean beef that serves as the perfect canvas; look for vibrant red color and a fine grain with minimal fat
• Large Shrimp: peeled and deveined for quick cooking and a sweet, briny bite; fresh or frozen works, just thaw fully if frozen
• Lobster Meat: chopped into bite-sized pieces; fresh is best but good-quality frozen lobster ensures that luxe flavor without a trip to the coast
• Heavy Cream: thickens the sauce and adds richness; opt for full-fat cream for best results
• Garlic: fresh minced for pungency and fragrance, avoid pre-minced to keep that vibrant punch
• Butter: essential for sautéing and building the sauce’s silky texture; use unsalted for better flavor control
• White Wine (optional): adds a bright acidity to balance the cream; choose a dry variety like Sauvignon Blanc
• Fresh Parsley: brightens and freshens the finished dish; pick bunches with deep green stems and no wilted leaves

When shopping, I like to pick my seafood last so it stays cold and fresh throughout my prep. Also, for the filet, visiting a butcher shop rather than a standard grocery means you can ask for steaks cut to your preferred thickness, which makes timing the cook easier.

Cooking Process

Searing the Filet Mignon:

This step locks in juices and develops a caramelized crust that brings savory depth. Medium-high heat and patience ensure the perfect steak edge without overcooking interiors.

Building the Seafood Base:

Garlic’s quick sauté unlocks fragrance while the butter bath gently cooks shrimp and lobster, preserving their delicate texture and sweetness.

Deglazing the Pan:

Using white wine lifts the browned bits from the pan’s bottom, infusing the sauce with rich, toasty flavors that elevate the whole dish.

Simmering the Cream Sauce:

A gentle simmer thickens heavy cream, concentrating flavors and binding seafood pieces into a silky, elegant coating.

Rest and Plate:

Letting the steak rest before plating redistributes juices for a tender bite; pouring the sauce over elevates each mouthful with decadent richness.

Save Pin

Recipe Highlights

After a few attempts, I once accidentally added the cream too soon, curdling it slightly. That hiccup taught me to keep the heat low and add cream gradually—it’s the kind of “oops” that makes a home cook wiser instantly. I’ve also played around with swapping parsley for chives when I’m feeling adventurous, adding a subtle oniony lift.

Flavor Variations

• Swap white wine for a squeeze of fresh lemon juice and a pinch of smoked paprika for a bright, smoky tang
• For a spicy twist, toss in red pepper flakes when sautéing garlic to give the sauce an electrifying kick
• Switch lobster out for crab meat to keep things local and budget-friendly without losing that crustacean sweetness

Make-ahead Strategies

• Season and sear steaks up to 2 hours before serving, keeping them loosely tented at room temperature
• Prepare the garlic butter seafood ahead and gently rewarm in the cream sauce when ready to serve to save time

Kitchen Tool Recommendations

• Heavy-bottomed skillet or cast iron pan for even heat retention during searing
• Flexible silicone spatula to gently stir seafood without breaking it apart
• Instant-read thermometer to hit steak temperature just right without guesswork

Cooking Secrets

• Rest the Filet: Allow steaks to rest 5-7 minutes after cooking; this step keeps juices locked in, delivering tender, juicy bites.
• Gentle Sauce Simmer: Low and slow with the cream prevents curdling and promotes a smooth, glossy finish.
• Don’t Crowd the Pan: Cook shrimp and lobster in batches if needed to avoid steaming and keep the texture firm and succulent.

Save Pin

Common Questions

→ How do I ensure the filet mignon stays tender?

Season the steaks well and cook them to medium-rare by searing on each side for about 3-4 minutes. Let them rest before serving to keep juices locked in.

→ Can I skip the white wine in the sauce?

Yes, the white wine is optional and can be omitted. The sauce will still be rich and flavorful with garlic, cream, and butter.

→ What’s the best way to cook shrimp and lobster for this dish?

Sauté the shrimp and lobster in butter just until the shrimp turn pink and the lobster is heated through, about 2-3 minutes, to prevent overcooking.

→ How thick should the sauce be before serving?

Simmer the cream gently until it thickens to coat the back of a spoon. This ensures a velvety texture that complements the steak and seafood.

→ What sides pair well with this entree?

Creamy mashed potatoes or steamed asparagus enhance the flavors and provide a balanced plate.