Save Pin
When you want something warm and satisfying but can't decide what to cook, this old-school patty melt really hits the spot. Toasty golden bread, gooey stretchy cheese, and juicy beef always bring everyone to the table—I'm talking even the picky folks in my house.
I didn’t believe something so straightforward could turn out so tasty the first time I gave this a go. But my crew won’t stop asking for it whenever we're in the mood for that classic diner food vibe.
Mouthwatering Ingredients
- Provolone cheese: Silky and melts into every corner, making every bite rich
- Cheddar cheese: Zippy and sharp, try grabbing the real deal instead of plastic-wrapped slices
- White sugar: A tiny sprinkle makes the sauce just a bit sweet and balanced
- Sweet relish: Tosses in a little tang and crunchy texture for fun
- Real bacon bits: Smoky and crispy—these make each sandwich pop, just check you’re using real bacon
- Ketchup: Sweet and tangy, lifts the sauce flavor
- Mayonnaise: Keeps the sauce super creamy, and full-fat gives the best texture
- Onion powder: Adds gentle onion flavor without making the whole thing taste like onion soup—make sure it's fresh
- Sea salt: Fine grains blend super easy, and the saltiness balances the beef nicely
- Ground black pepper: For a little warmth and bite, fresh is best if you've got a grinder
- Ground beef: 80/20 is juicy and soft, and buying it fresh (not frozen) keeps it tender
- Butter: Spread it while soft so the slices toast up just right—go for the good stuff if you can
- Rye bread: Thick and tangy, pick hearty slices so they don't get soggy
Simple How-To Steps
- Toast and Serve:
- Pop the sandwich in your pan for 2 to 3 minutes per side till you see a golden outside and the inside is all melty. Do this for every sandwich and eat right away for max crunch.
- Add Sauce and Top Bread:
- Grab the last bread slice and slather sauce over the side without butter. Flip that over and press it gently on the stack of cheese and meat.
- Assemble the Patty Melts:
- Heat a new pan on medium-low. Set bread butter-side-down in the pan, lay down a couple cheddar slices, stack on a warm burger, then top with provolone.
- Make the Sauce:
- While patties finish up, stir together mayo, ketchup, bacon pieces, relish, and sugar. You want a creamy spread with bacon bits everywhere—set close by since you'll use it in a sec.
- Check Temperature:
- If you're nervous about doneness, poke a meat thermometer into the middle. It should read 160°F—that's when you know it's safe and ready.
- Cook the Patties:
- Warm up a nonstick pan on medium-high, set down the patties, and don't poke them for about 3 minutes so a tasty crust can form. Flip and cook another 3 minutes. Lower the heat and let them finish for about 5 more minutes until they're fully browned inside—no pink left.
- Mix and Form Patties:
- In a bowl, add beef, black pepper, onion powder, and sea salt. Use your hands to gently blend and shape into 3 even patties. Don't squish them, just enough to hold together.
- Prepare the Bread:
- Grab each rye slice and spread a thick coat of butter on one side. Lay them out flat to make building the sandwich a breeze.
Save Pin
Patty melts take me right back to kid days, stopping for diner food with my dad. Nothing like a grilled sandwich and cold soda after school—those memories always bring good vibes.
Saving Leftovers
If you end up with extras, let them cool off before wrapping snug in foil. Toss 'em in the fridge and eat within two days. Toss leftovers into a skillet on low heat to get the crispy crust and gooey cheese again. Microwave only if you're in a pinch—the bread won't stay crisp, but it works.
Easy Ingredient Swaps
If rye isn't around, use sourdough or thick-sliced white bread for a gentler flavor. No cheddar or provolone? Monterey Jack or Swiss does the trick. You can even toss in chopped pickles or onions instead of relish for a change.
Tasty Ways to Enjoy
Top off your meal with kettle chips and pickle slices for that diner vibe. Goes well with a pile of coleslaw or a fresh simple salad. Want more food? Serve up with sweet potato fries or oven fries on the side.
Save Pin
Fun Patty Melt Backstory
Patty melts first showed up in American greasy spoons in the 1950s, basically blending a hamburger and grilled cheese into one awesome sandwich. People loved that it tasted familiar yet wasn’t just a plain burger—and now you’ll find one at just about any diner in America.
Common Questions
- → Which bread holds up best for a patty melt?
Go for rye bread. It’s got a solid crunch and bold taste that goes awesome with cheese and beef. Plus, it won’t fall apart on the grill.
- → How do I keep my patties together when turning them?
Let them cook on one side without fussing, then carefully flip them using a big spatula so they don’t fall apart.
- → What cheeses should I use?
Cheddar kicks in a sharp bite, while Provolone melts smooth. Mix them for a rich, melty center that works every time.
- → When can I tell my beef is done?
Poke a thermometer in the middle. If it hits 160°F (71°C), you’re good—the beef’s cooked all the way through.
- → Can I mix in extra toppings or switch things up?
For sure—throw on some caramelized onions or swipe a little mustard. Feel free to change the sauce with whatever condiments you love.