Save Pin
Hot, comforting hash browns loaded with melty cheese always hit the spot—no wonder they're a huge hit when Cracker Barrel-style potatoes show up. Once baked, the inside’s all smooth and cheesy and the top turns that perfect golden brown. People ask for seconds the minute you set it out, so don’t expect leftovers if you bring it to a brunch or a potluck!
My first go with this was at a holiday morning when I wanted something that's special but not a hassle. Now, it’s every gathering—we don’t do brunch without it and people always ask for it by name.
Dreamy Ingredients
- Colby cheese, grated: Melts perfectly and tastes just tangy enough. Freshly grated cheese melts even smoother and goes further.
- Frozen shredded hash browns: Go for sturdy brands like Ore Ida—they bake up nice and don’t turn soggy. Avoid any bags with icy chunks for better results.
- Onion, finely chopped: Brings a gentle sweetness and makes every bite more flavorful. Chop it tiny so it spreads all over.
- Cream of mushroom soup: Smooths out the mix and packs tons of savory flavor. Store-bought is great or make your own if you’re fancy.
- Cream of celery soup: Makes things extra lush and tosses in herby flavor. Little celery pieces in the soup are a win!
- Margarine: Helps the top get that crispy golden look. Butter does the trick too if you want deeper flavor.
Simple Steps
- Heat the Oven:
- Set your oven to 350 F and give it time to heat. Spray a 13-by-9 pan with oil so nothing sticks.
- Mix it All Together:
- Pop the hash browns in a big bowl with the soups, onion, and half the cheese. Stir everything until the soup coats it all.
- Spread in Pan:
- Push the cheesy potato blend into your ready pan. Get those corners and flatten it out for an even bake.
- Top with Margarine and Cheese:
- Sprinkle the rest of the Colby cheese over the top. Dot little bits of margarine so the crust bubbles and browns.
- Let it Bake:
- Bake uncovered on the oven’s middle rack for forty-five minutes. The cheese should look melty and bubbling at the edges, starting to brown. If you want, bake a few more minutes for an extra crusty top.
Save Pin
Keeping & Using Extras
Let it cool off before covering with foil and putting in the fridge—it’ll last up to three days. For more time, chop into squares, plastic-wrap them, and stash in the freezer. Thaw overnight in the fridge, then warm at 300 F to get that crispy edge back.
Fun Variations
No Colby? Cheddar, mozzarella or even a mix will be just as tasty. For lighter eats, swap some soup with Greek yogurt or homemade creamy sauce using milk and flour. Vegetarians can grab any meat-free canned soups. Each tweak changes up the feel and keeps it interesting.
Serving Tips
Grab a scoop alongside bacon and eggs at brunch. Next to roast chicken or glazed ham, it’s killer at dinner. For a crispy edge, reheat squares in a hot pan the next day. Chopped chives or green onions give a fresh lift sprinkled on right before serving.
Save Pin
A Little History
This comfort food comes from Southern kitchens where cheesy potatoes are a must for cozy get-togethers. Cracker Barrel’s classic version made them super popular with old-fashioned, homey twists. You’ll spot big trays of these at church potlucks and family breakfasts everywhere.
Common Questions
- → Is it okay to swap Colby for another cheese?
Absolutely! Cheddar, Monterey Jack, or any cheesy favorite will swap in nice. The taste and texture will change a bit, but you do you.
- → Should the hash browns be soft or can I just toss them in frozen?
Letting the potatoes thaw a bit mixes things together smoother, but frozen is fine in a pinch. Just plan for extra bake time till it’s cooked through.
- → Can I bump up the flavor with meat or veggies?
Totally! Mix in bacon, ham, mushrooms, or bell peppers if you want it heartier or want to play with flavors.
- → I’m out of margarine. What’s my move?
Butter swaps in perfectly and actually makes it even richer and more old-school tasty.
- → How do I spot when it’s ready to eat?
The top will be golden with little crispy patches, and the center will be hot all the way through. That’s your sign to dig in!