Save Pin
Whenever I'm craving something with all the bold taste of an Italian deli sub but don't feel like turning on the oven, I whip up this cool, pasta-packed salad. You get zingy meat, tangy pickled veggies, cheese cubes, and crisp lettuce tangled up with noodles. Everybody digs in—it's way more fun than a regular old sandwich, especially when there's a crowd around.
The first time I brought this to a BBQ, folks were sneaking seconds long before the burgers even hit the table. These days, it's my potluck standby. It vanishes faster than anything else I make.
Tasty Ingredients
- Romaine lettuce, shredded: the crunch holds up even with dressing
- Grape tomatoes, halved: sweet and juicy little bursts
- Pink onion, chopped: mild for just a bit of bite
- Sliced black olives: plump and soft with a nice brined flavor
- Banana peppers, chopped: you want them tangy, firm, and bright yellow
- Provolone cheese, cubed: go for the sharper kind if you love extra flavor
- Muenster cheese, cubed: brings a creamy touch that balances the zip
- Mini pepperoni: grab the tiny rounds so every bite has some meat
- Salami, chopped: the spicier and pepperier, the better it tastes
- Dry pasta: twisty shapes like Loopdy-Loos are best for scooping up dressing
Simple Step-by-Step Instructions
- Dress and Chill:
- Drizzle your dressing evenly over the full bowl, tossing everything to coat every bit. Cover with plastic wrap and let it hang out in the fridge for about an hour so flavors blend nicely. Give it all a big toss again before serving.
- Make the Dressing:
- Mix up your favorite Italian dressing or hoagie-style spread in a small bowl. Whisk it like you mean it so it turns creamy and everything comes together.
- Mix Up Veggies, Cheeses, and Meats:
- Toss in all your salami, mini pepperoni, the cheese cubes, olives, chopped onion, halved tomatoes, peppers, and lettuce with your cooked pasta. Use some big spoons and mix until everything looks even.
- Boil Your Pasta:
- Bring a hefty pot of salted water to a boil, pour in the pasta, and cook until it's just right—al dente is best for this. Dump it into a colander, run under cold water to chill, shake off extra drops, then toss it all into a giant bowl.
Save Pin
Honestly, I'm obsessed with the banana peppers. That zingy snap cuts through everything else and brings me right back to grabbing hoagies with my cousins at the beach every summer.
Keeping It Fresh
This salad keeps great up to two days if you stash it covered in the fridge. Make sure to toss it before dishing up since things settle on the bottom. Dry? Just splash on more dressing or a slick of olive oil to bring it back.
Swap-In Ideas
Use whatever you've got! Mozzarella or cheddar works instead of muenster if you want it sharper. Craving spice? Hot capicola replaces salami nicely. Not into banana peppers? Sliced red bell pepper fits right in.
Save Pin
Fun Ways to Serve
Pile it high on a serving platter and sprinkle with more lettuce for a deli-style vibe. It's perfect next to grilled brats or paired with a simple veggie soup. At parties, I spoon it into little cups so everyone can grab and munch.
The Story Behind This Dish
Think classic Italian-American deli subs—stuffed with meats, cheese, and pickles. Turning that into a pasta salad is just a fun, tasty way to stretch those flavors for a crowd. It’s what I love about remaking comfort food favs for a party table.
Common Questions
- → What type of pasta works best?
Pick short, tough pasta shapes—think penne, rotini, or Loopdy-Loos—because they catch that dressing and stick with the mix-ins. Don't overcook; you want a little bite in there.
- → Can I substitute meats or cheeses?
Totally! Toss in ham, turkey, cheddar, or mozzarella—whatever you've got on hand. Change up deli meats and cheeses to keep things fun.
- → How long does this salad keep?
Pop it in the fridge, covered, and it'll keep tasting great for a couple of days. Just give it a toss before digging in again.
- → Is the pepper relish required?
They aren't a must, but sweet or spicy pepper relishes bring extra zip. If you've got hoagie spread or jarred hot pepper mix, go for it!
- → What's a good way to serve this dish?
Keep it cold and dish it up as the main event, or serve it with barbecue or grilled stuff. Load it up with lettuce or crisp veggies for even more crunch.