Tasty Chicken Shawarma Sauce

There’s just something special about really good chicken shawarma—juicy chicken, bold zesty spices, and a smoky kick from cumin. You’ll taste hints of paprika, turmeric and warm cinnamon all in every bite. Fill up a hot, soft pita with loads of chicken, slather on ice-cold garlic sauce, and you’ll see why it’s so hard to stop. The secret? Letting the chicken soak in all those spices for hours. The longer it hangs out, the tastier it gets—totally matches what you’d get from a food truck or your favorite spot.

Cooking up shawarma from scratch totally changed the dinner game after I’d had enough takeout. The very first time I tossed those spices together, the smell basically brought my whole family to the kitchen. Once we sat down, everyone was quiet during the first bites (which always means it’s a hit). Even my pickiest kid, who never wants to try anything new, came back for seconds. Now, I always make extra to use in salads or for speedy lunches later on.

Mouthwatering Ingredients List

• 2 pounds boneless, skinless chicken thighs: Juicy thighs soak up flavor and stay tender, even if you get busy and cook them a tad too long.
• 3 tablespoons olive oil: Extra virgin is best for a richer sauce, but any will do—helps spices stick like glue to the chicken.
• 2 teaspoons ground cumin: That classic shawarma flavor you can’t fake—go big or go home!
• 2 teaspoons paprika: Sweet or spicy, your choice. It brings a pop of color and flavor depth.
• 1 teaspoon ground turmeric: Brings golden color and soft earthiness, tying up those flavors.
• 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon: Adds warmth and a cozy hit of aroma. Trust me, don’t skip it!
• 1 tablespoon lemon juice: Fresh is key. Keeps it bright and tenderizes the meat at the same time.
• 4 garlic cloves, minced: Real garlic is the way. Go fresh, not from a jar, for the best taste.
• Salt and pepper, to taste: Kosher salt really makes things pop, so season well.

Delicious Garlicky Sauce

• ½ cup Greek yogurt: Full-fat is creamiest, but low-fat gets you pretty close. Serious tang!
• 2 tablespoons mayonnaise: Makes it smooth, creamy, and takes off any sharp edge from garlic.
• 3 garlic cloves, minced: Raw is punchy, but let it rest in the sauce if you want it milder.
• 1 tablespoon lemon juice: Brightens things and lifts the garlic flavor without being sour.
• Salt and pepper, to taste: Taste at the end and add just a pinch more to perfect it.

Save Pin

Super Easy Step-by-Step

Hand Off the Wraps:

Grab warm flatbread, lay a swipe of garlic sauce, add sliced chicken and toss on whatever toppings you love—try pickles, onions, lettuce or tomatoes. Fold up the bottom, roll snug, and enjoy on the spot!

Rest and Slice:

Pull your chicken off the heat. Let it chill for about five minutes so you don’t lose the juices. Slice thinly, against the grain, about a quarter inch wide. Any pieces that look underdone? Toss ’em back in the pan real quick.

Crank the Heat:

Planning to grill? Heat to 375-400°F. Oven? Fire it up to 425°F and line a tray with parchment. Skillet? It’s ready when drops of water sizzle and vanish. You need high heat for those little caramelized bits.

Get Cooking:

On the grill: Lay out chicken, oil the grates, and cook 5-7 minutes each side, until the inside hits 165°F. In the oven: Bake 20-25 minutes, flipping halfway. For stovetop, use a hot cast iron with some oil, 5-7 minutes per side, letting the edges brown and char for best results.

Mix Up the Sauce:

While the chicken rests, mix mayo, Greek yogurt, lemon, and garlic in a small bowl. Salt and pepper to taste. Want it punchier? Add more garlic or lemon, and let sit for a bit—it’s even better the next day.

Make the Marinade:

Stir olive oil, spices, lemon juice, and garlic until smooth and deep red. Smells awesome already—this is the beginning of serious flavor!

Soak Up the Spices:

Put chicken in a sealed plastic bag or shallow bowl, add marinade, and use your hands to smear all over. Don’t want yellow fingers? Wear gloves—turmeric stains! Chill it for an hour minimum, or all night if you can wait. The extra time pays off in flavor.

Serve and Enjoy:

Slice the finished wraps in two or leave them whole and pile onto a plate. Bring extra sauce and fixings to the table—let everyone load up their own. Nothing beats warm chicken with cool, garlicky sauce.

Unbeatable Chicken Shawarma

Don’t Skip These

At a sunny backyard BBQ, my Lebanese neighbor took a bite and looked shocked—in a good way. He asked where I learned, and I said it was all just experimenting. He smiled wide and told me his family uses a pinch of cinnamon every time. I always remember that now, adding it in and thinking about how each cook tweaks things a little and shares stories through food.

Balancing Flavor in Every Bite

It’s not just about spicy chicken and zingy garlic sauce—the sides are huge. Use the best flatbread or swap for lavash or even a tortilla. Warm the bread up for the best texture. Add crisp and tart toppings like cucumbers, fresh tomato, or tangy pickled veggies for a fun mix in every mouthful. Every extra layer makes your food sing.

Chicken Shawarma Travels the World

The coolest thing about chicken shawarma is how it travels everywhere, picking up local flavors. It started in Turkey, spread across the Middle East, and every country put their own twist—garlic sauce (toum) in Lebanon, dukkah or tahini in Egypt. Immigrants took those spins everywhere—New York, Berlin, Sydney. Every time you cook this at home, you join that big, tasty story and make it your own way.

Switch Up How You Serve

Wraps are awesome, but leftovers go far. Try tossing this chicken over rice or couscous, flooding it with sauce and cool veggies. Mix with eggs, sprinkle on feta and fresh herbs—breakfast win! Put everything on a tray for everyone to build wraps their way. It even turns a salad into a full meal—avocado and lemon juice pair perfectly.

Marination: It's Worth The Wait

Give your chicken time to chill in marinade—seriously, it changes everything. Lemon softens the meat, salt brings out moisture and then locks it back in, olive oil sneaks spices into every bit. If you need to rush, lightly pound or score the thighs, but trust me, overnight in the fridge is the real ticket to flavor.

Save Pin

Adapt for Any Diet

Easy to make friendly for everyone. Need dairy-free sauce? Use coconut yogurt or blend soaked cashews with a little water for creaminess. Going gluten-free? Pile chicken and toppings over rice or just stick with veggies. No carbs? Go for a hearty salad or add grilled veggies. No meat? Try the marinade on tofu, mushrooms, or big cauliflower steaks. Same great flavor, different base!

I’ve tweaked this over lots of tries, and shawarma shows how you don’t need fancy stuff for epic taste—just patience and basics from your pantry. The first time I made this for my whole family, everyone just smiled and went quiet while eating. It’s magic watching people realize homemade can be just as good as their favorite takeout. Spiced chicken with cool garlic sauce brings everyone closer, whether it’s a big crowd or just a regular Tuesday night.

Common Questions

→ Can I use chicken breast instead of thighs?

Totally works, but thighs keep their juiciness better. If you try breast, watch your cook time so it doesn't dry out, and you might want to toss in an extra spoonful of olive oil to keep it moist.

→ What about making it dairy-free?

Absolutely! Just pick a plant yogurt—think coconut, almond, or soy based. The taste changes a little, but it still rocks.

→ Best veggies to toss in?

Go for pickled bits, fresh lettuce, tomato slices, cucumber, or onions. Whip up a quick cucumber-tomato salad if you’re in a hurry. Always good!

→ How can I turn up the heat?

You bet! Dash in some chili flakes for your garlic sauce, add hot sauce, or use a bit of cayenne in the marinade to give it a good kick.

→ How long does garlic sauce keep in the fridge?

Stays good for about five days if it’s sealed tight and cold. Works awesome for dipping or sandwiches too.