Cinnamon Roll Poke Cake

The first time I made this Cinnamon Roll Poke Cake, the house was filled with that irresistible scent of cinnamon and sweet vanilla—just like stepping into a cozy bakery on a chilly morning. It all started on a whim, craving those warm, gooey cinnamon rolls but without the hours of dough rising. Using a simple white cake mix, I found a way to capture all that flavor with a fraction of the fuss. From the moment the butter and brown sugar syrup seeped into the soft cake, I knew I stumbled onto something special.

I first discovered this technique watching a friend prepare a poke cake at a summer potluck. The idea of poking holes for filling to soak through fascinated me—after years of experimenting, I realized it’s the secret to irresistibly moist desserts.

Essential Ingredients

• White cake mix: provides a tender, fluffy base; choose your favorite brand but stick with white for that clean, sweet flavor
• Butter: richness and moisture; use unsalted so you control flavor perfectly
• Light brown sugar: adds a subtle molasses undertone that pairs beautifully with cinnamon. Look for a packed container rather than loose
• Ground cinnamon: delivers that classic warm spice; fresh-ground will always give a more vibrant taste
• Clear vanilla extract: keeps frosting bright white with pure vanilla aroma; swap with regular vanilla if preferred, but expect a creamier color
• Sweetened condensed milk: sweet and creamy syrup that seeps deep into the cake, making it moist and luscious
• Cream cheese: softens frosting with a tangy richness; let it come to room temperature for best creaming results
• Powdered sugar: sweetens and stabilizes frosting texture, adding smoothness and fluffiness

At the store, check cream cheese for firmness and a clean scent, and pick powdered sugar with no lumps by shaking the container gently.

Cooking Process

Baking the Base:

Mix and bake the cake just as directed, watching closely since box mixes often bake faster; this keeps the cake soft and tender. Cooling it until just warm allows the filling to absorb without sinking too quickly.

Poking the Cake:

Use the end of a silicone spatula to poke holes about half an inch apart. Gently pressing while the cake is still warm keeps the surface intact but ready to soak up syrup.

Infusing the Filling:

Whisk butter, brown sugar, cinnamon, vanilla, and sweetened condensed milk until smooth. Heat in short bursts to dissolve sugar clumps, making a thick, rich syrup that drizzles evenly into cake holes.

Creaming the Frosting:

Beat softened butter and cream cheese until fluffy before gradually adding powdered sugar, vanilla, and half and half. This careful mixing builds a smooth frosting that spreads easily while holding a light texture.

Smoothing the Finish:

Spread frosting evenly over the cake with a silicone spatula or offset knife. Serve right away or chill for a firmer slice and pairing with ice cream.

Save Pin

Recipe Highlights

• Comfort dessert that feels like cinnamon rolls without the work
• Moist cake with gooey pockets of cinnamon-sugar goodness
• Cream cheese frosting that balances sweetness with a subtle tang

One time, I rushed the frosting and added all the powdered sugar at once—resulting in a gritty texture and spiked sweetness. Lesson learned here: patience makes creamy perfection.

Make-Ahead Strategies

This cake actually improves a bit after resting. Bake, fill, and frost, then cover tightly and refrigerate overnight. The syrup settles deeper into the cake, and chilling firms the frosting for neater slices the next day. Just bring to room temp before serving for soft, melt-in-your-mouth comfort.

Flavor Variations

Swap the cinnamon for pumpkin pie spice in fall for a seasonal twist. A splash of bourbon in the syrup also adds depth if you're feeling adventurous. Top frosting with chopped pecans for crunch, or swirl in caramel sauce for extra richness.

Kitchen Tool Recommendations

A long-offset icing spatula speeds up frosting application and helps smooth edges effortlessly. Using a silicone spatula end for poking doesn’t tear the cake like forks or chopsticks sometimes do, keeping the top pretty. A stand mixer is ideal for fluffy frosting but handheld works just fine.

Cooking Secrets

• Warm cake slightly before poking holes to keep the surface intact and maximize syrup absorption
• Heat filling slowly, stirring well to dissolve sugar completely—no clumps means even flavor pockets
• Add powdered sugar little by little to frosting for the perfect silky texture without grittiness

Save Pin

Common Questions

→ What makes the cake moist and flavorful?

The cake becomes moist by poking holes and pouring a warm cinnamon-sugar and butter mixture over it, allowing the flavors to soak in deeply.

→ How is the frosting prepared for this dessert?

The frosting is a smooth blend of softened cream cheese, butter, powdered sugar, vanilla, and half-and-half, whipped until creamy and fluffy.

→ Can I use regular vanilla extract instead of clear vanilla flavoring?

Yes, regular vanilla extract can be used, but clear vanilla helps keep the frosting bright white.

→ Is it better to serve this dessert warm or chilled?

It’s delicious served immediately while slightly warm or chilled to enjoy a firmer texture and refreshing taste.

→ What tools are recommended for poking holes in the cake?

An end of a silicone spoon, spatula, or wooden handled spatula works well to create even, spaced holes without damaging the cake surface.