Save Pin
Walking in after a tough day and catching that cheesy, beefy scent is just the best. This slow cooker steak and cheddar potato casserole is what you want when your belly needs something filling but you don’t feel like stirring over the stove. You’ll get melty cheddar, chunks of steak, and soft potatoes in every bite. It’s cozy and super easy, too.
This is always my go-to for family nights because plates are cleared fast. The very first time I dished it up, even my picky kiddo loved it more than any takeout and wanted leftovers packed up the next day.
Delicious Ingredients
- Butter: Makes the steak nice and brown plus adds that creamy feel Go with unsalted if you can
- Garlic: Adds a punch of savory flavor Fresh cloves honestly work best and smell amazing
- Onion: Brings subtle sweetness and more flavor Pick firm ones with dry skin
- Black pepper: Gives a bit of mild spice and pulls everything together Fresh cracked is best
- Salt: Helps all the flavors pop Try kosher for easy sprinkling
- Smoked paprika: Adds a deep smoky kick and makes the color gorgeous Spanish types are top notch
- Sirloin or ribeye steak cubes: Super tasty and tender when slow-cooked Look for juicy, marbled pieces
- Russet or Yukon Gold potatoes: Perfectly soft in the slow cooker Yukon Golds are extra buttery
- Sharp cheddar cheese: Grate your own for better melt and punchier taste Aged white or orange works
- Heavy cream: Rounds out the sauce with extra creaminess Always use fresh-smelling cream
- Beef broth: Adds that deep, meaty backdrop Go for low salt so you’re in charge of seasonings
Simple How-To Guide
- Cook It Low and Slow
- Pop the lid on and let it chill out for six to eight hours on low or three to four hours if you’re in a hurry The potatoes should easily pierce with a fork and the top gets golden Let it sit ten minutes so everything thickens
- Add the Cheese
- Generously cover everything with the cheddar so it melts and crisps up slightly up top
- Pour On Cream and Broth
- Evenly pour in the broth and cream over all those layers Drop in more salt and pepper if that’s your thing This makes the casserole nice and creamy
- Layer Your Potatoes and Steak
- Start with half the potatoes, overlapping in the bottom of your slow cooker Sprinkle half the onion and garlic over top Dump in the seared steak pieces Layer on the rest of the potatoes followed by the rest of the onion and garlic That way you get all the flavors in every scoop
- Sear the Steak First
- Heat butter in a pan over medium-high Toss in steak cubes that you’ve dusted with smoked paprika, salt, and black pepper Sear until they’re brown all over and the outside gets a good crust This step makes the whole casserole rich and deep
Save Pin
Smoked paprika is a must-do for me ever since my grandma used it with every steak she cooked. Whenever I catch that hint of smoky spice, it’s like getting a warm hug from those old Sunday dinners. Worth every sprinkle.
Easy Storage Advice
Stick leftovers in an airtight box and stash them in the fridge for up to three days. Let things cool before sealing them or you’ll get soggy condensation. If you want to freeze it, spoon out individual servings for handy reheating. Warm it up in the oven under foil so it stays moist and tasty.
Swaps and Switch-Ups
No sirloin or ribeye? Grab a chuck steak or stew beef if your budget needs a break. Monterey Jack swaps in for cheddar if you want extra melty bites. Lighten things up with half and half and low fat cheese instead of the heavy stuff. Try sweet potatoes if you’d like the casserole to be a little more colorful and sweet.
Save Pin
How to Serve It
This casserole really doesn’t need much but pairs well with something fresh, like a simple salad or some crispy Brussels sprouts. Throw on some chives or sour cream if you want to get fancy. Crusty bread or toasted rolls make each scoop even more satisfying.
Tasty Traditions
Casseroles with potatoes pop up in all sorts of cultures—they’re cheap and so hearty. Mixing beef and potatoes in one pot nods at classic American meals and old-school French dishes like au gratin. Crockpots took off in the seventies because they brought families together round a hot, homey meal. This dish keeps that vibe alive, just even cheesier now.
Common Questions
- → Could I swap in another kind of beef?
Sure thing. Chuck or stew meat works, too. If you pick a tougher cut, just let it cook longer so it gets all tender.
- → Is it best to leave skins on or off the potatoes?
Peeled potatoes turn out extra smooth, but keeping the skins adds a cozy, rustic bite and more nutrition. Go with what you like.
- → How do I make sure it’s not too wet?
Choose starchy spuds like Russet and skip rinsing them off. Slice them up evenly and don’t toss in extra liquid unless you want it that way.
- → Can I put everything together ahead of time?
Yup. Layer it all the night before and stash in the fridge. Just turn on the slow cooker come morning, super easy.
- → What’s a quick way to bump up the flavor?
Throw in fresh herbs such as rosemary or thyme, or sprinkle on some chives or green onions when it’s done for a tasty finish.
- → Which sides match this main?
This plays great alongside a crisp salad, roasted veggies, or some crusty bread. Total comfort on the table.