Save Pin
Imagine a hot baked potato loaded up with juicy steak pieces and drowned in a creamy parmesan sauce. That’s what you get with this combo: steakhouse vibes in a cozy potato, easy enough for any weeknight. It’s my trick for putting together a hearty dinner that still feels special without making it complicated.
I actually made this on a cold weekend. My family was begging for steak, but I had only a little steak and a few potatoes. Once I stuffed those potatoes with steak, creamy sauce, and all, there wasn’t even a crumb left.
Tasty Ingredients
- Russet potatoes, big ones: You want these for that crispy skin but soft insides. Avoid spuds with green spots or weird marks.
- Sea salt: Makes the potato skin tasty and boosts flavor all through
- Olive oil: Rub this on outside so you get crunchy skins. Extra virgin kind works best.
- Steak: Use tenderloin, ribeye, NY strip, or sirloin. Grab what’s affordable. Trim off chewy bits for super tender results.
- Kosher salt: Hefty flakes make steak extra tasty. Add more if needed.
- Cajun seasoning: Bumps up the flavor on those steak cubes. Try low-salt blends.
- Butter: Makes everything rich and is perfect for sauce or fluffy potato insides. Get unsalted if you can.
- Heavy cream: The key for that dreamy, smooth sauce. Go for the freshest option you find.
- Lemon: Little squeeze brightens up every bite. Fresh is best.
- Avocado oil: Steak browns quick in this thanks to its high smoke point.
- Fresh garlic: Gives punchy flavor. Mince right before so it’s super fragrant.
- Parmesan cheese: Nutty and salty kick. Grab a wedge and grate yourself, trust me.
- Red pepper flakes: Heat and a pop of color. Crush them a bit for a stronger aroma.
- Fresh parsley: Chopped leaves make things look fresh and taste zippy.
- Fresh cracked pepper: Adds real depth and just a bit of bite—so much better than powder.
Simple Step List
- Stuff and Finish the Potatoes:
- Give your baked spuds a smack on the table so the inside gets loose and fluffy. Make a deep cut but don’t go all the way through. Grab a fork and fluff the hot inside, then add a dab of butter for extra yum. Load up with steak pieces and pour over the creamy parmesan sauce till it oozes out. Serve while steaming hot.
- Make That Creamy Parmesan Sauce:
- Take your same pan, melt leftover butter and toss in the rest of the garlic. Let it cook ’til it’s just fragrant. Slowly pour in heavy cream, scraping up any browned pan bits, and keep it at a gentle bubble for a few minutes until it thickens. Throw in red pepper and parmesan, whisk till smooth, taste for salt or pepper. Take off the heat. Mix in diced parsley and a squirt of lemon.
- Make the Garlic Butter Steak:
- Scoot steak to the side of the pan once it’s ready. Drop in half your chopped garlic plus two spoonfuls of butter into the empty spot. Let it smell toasty, then toss the steak cubes till butter coats each one. Let them sizzle one last time, then transfer to a bowl and loosely cover to stay moist.
- Sear the Steak:
- As spuds bake, cut steak into two inch chunks and ditch any chewy bits. Toss it with half your avocado oil, a good shake of Cajun spice, and lots of kosher salt. Pop the rest of the oil in a screaming hot cast iron skillet. Space out steak bites in the pan—don’t pile them! Sear two minutes per side, flip once, and lower heat for the last minute.
- Bake the Potatoes:
- Fire your oven up to four twenty five and prep your baking tray with parchment. Scrub potatoes and dry them, then coat each with oil and sea salt. Lay them out with a little gap between each. Don’t poke them! Bake fifty to sixty minutes until totally soft inside.
Save Pin
Good to Know
- Meal stays free from gluten, naturally
- Steak cooks best when spaced out—don’t crowd or it’ll stay soggy
- Put it all together right before eating for best flavor and texture
My house loves steak and potatoes, but this cheesy sauce takes it next level. My kids basically fight over the one with the most sauce, so I always make a little extra to keep the peace.
Keeping Leftovers
Stick leftover potato-stuffed steaks in a lidded container in your fridge for up to two days. To warm them up, cover with foil and heat in your oven, then top with more sauce so it doesn’t dry out. You can also stash the steak and sauce in the freezer for up to two months, but don’t freeze the filled potatoes or they’ll turn weird and grainy in texture.
Swaps Welcome
No steak? Chicken thighs or big mushrooms work too—makes a great meatless meal. Try sweet potatoes if you want something different. Out of heavy cream? Whole milk plus a bit more butter does the trick for a lighter sauce. Use whatever cheese you’ve got, like asiago or gruyere, if parmesan is missing from your fridge.
Save Pin
Fun Ways to Serve
Serve these loaded potatoes as your main alongside a quick green salad or some roasted broccoli. Mini baked potatoes turn this into a fun party bite. Drizzle hot sauce or pile on extra herbs if you want a little color and kick.
Backstory
Steak and taters are a staple in homes and old school steakhouses, especially in the Midwest and down South. This version jazzes things up a bit, bringing together familiar comfort eats with a restaurant-style sauce and that classic pan-seared technique.
Common Questions
- → What kind of steak works best?
Go for NY strip, sirloin, ribeye, or tenderloin since they’re all pretty soft to bite into. Any of those cuts taste great, just pick your favorite or the one that’s easiest on your wallet.
- → How do you get crispy baked potato skins?
Before baking, rub those potatoes with oil and salt, then crank up the oven. You’ll get skins that crunch with every bite.
- → Can I make the parmesan cream sauce ahead of time?
Yep, you can whip up the sauce earlier and warm it when you’re ready to eat. Just give it a good stir if it separated while sitting.
- → How do you keep steak bites juicy?
Sear the steak on high heat and don’t let it cook too long. When they’re done, toss with garlic butter, cover for a few, and let them rest to keep all those tasty juices in.
- → What are good topping alternatives?
Think chopped up chives, crumbled bacon, fried mushrooms, or more cheese if you’re feeling it—these make awesome toppers.
- → Can this be made vegetarian?
Try roasted veggies or mushrooms instead of steak—you’ll still get a hearty and filling meal with no meat.