Save Pin
I always whip up this Deviled Egg Mac Salad for easy summer gatherings and anytime I want to impress at a potluck. Every bite’s creamy, like those nostalgic deviled eggs but blended right into soft pasta curls. That smooth yolk sauce wraps around the noodles, making ’em extra comforting. Crunchy veggies give it a lively, fun bite too.
I took this dish to my folks’ barbecue and it got scooped up before anyone bit into a burger. Even my egg-hating cousin went back for seconds. Not kidding.
Delicious Ingredients
- Large eggs: Boil them up for soft yolks to mash into the dressing and dice the rest for texture
- Elbow macaroni: This pasta hugs all that creamy yolk goodness every time you scoop
- Mayonnaise: You want the real stuff here—it’s that rich base holding it together
- Yellow mustard: Don’t use Dijon This brings that signature sharp deviled egg kick
- Apple cider vinegar: Lifts the flavor and keeps it tasting fresh Go for raw, unfiltered for bonus points
- Sugar: Helps balance out the vinegar’s tang
- Garlic powder: A little background savory flavor makes a difference
- Paprika: Dust some on top for color and that tiny hint of smoky flavor—try Spanish style if you have it
- Salt and black pepper: Brightens flavor and wakes everything up
- Celery: Slice up those juicy stalks for a crisp, sweet snap
- Red onion: Brings bold color and zing Pick a mellow one if sharp onion’s not your thing
- Dill pickles: Dice ’em up for a burst of tangy crunch—the cold deli-section ones are best
- Fresh parsley: Optional but adds a fresh green look and livens up every bite
Easy How-To
- Sort Out the Eggs:
- Hard boil, then peel and halve the eggs. Scoop yolks into a big bowl, then chop whites into small pieces and set aside. Makes the sauce extra rich but gives the salad some nice texture too.
- Blend the Dressing:
- Mash those yolks with a fork until smooth, then add salt, pepper, paprika, sugar, garlic powder, vinegar, mustard, and mayo. Whisk or stir till it’s totally mixed and creamy. Taste and toss in more mustard or salt if you’re feeling it.
- Mix It All Up:
- Add those chopped egg whites, parsley, crunchy veggies, red onion, and pickles to your dressing with the macaroni. Gently fold it all together till everything’s coated evenly.
- Chill and Serve:
- Cover the bowl and stick it in the fridge for at least an hour. Sprinkle extra paprika before digging in. Cooler salad means better flavor and it’ll be perfectly set.
Save Pin
I love that sharp pickle bite mixed with the soft, rich egg sauce. Even my uncle, who’s never been a pasta salad fan, asked if he could take some home after our July Fourth barbecue.
Storing’s a Breeze
Pop your salad in the fridge with a snug lid. It’ll be fine for up to three days. If it dries out, just stir in a spoonful of mayo or a splash of vinegar before serving and you’re good to go.
Change Things Up
No dill pickles Don’t worry—swap in bread and butter pickles or even sweet gherkins. Add extra crunch with green pepper instead of celery. Cut some richness by going half mayo, half plain Greek yogurt.
Serving Ideas
Spoon it alongside anything grilled—burgers, hot dogs, or chicken. Or pile it over cold, crunchy romaine leaves for an easy lunch. It’s tasty stuffed into a wrap or sandwich with tomato, too.
Save Pin
Fun Deviled Egg History
Turns out folks in Ancient Rome were the first to make deviled eggs, but it really took off in the classic backyard parties of the 1950s. Mixing that with mac salad is just the best sort of flavor mashup, if you ask me.
Common Questions
- → What's the best way to make it super creamy?
Bring your mayo and eggs to room temp, smash the yolks all the way smooth, and mix gentle so your pasta stays full.
- → Can I use a different pasta?
Small pasta shapes like shells or rotini do best here. Skip the big or filled types, those don't soak up the dressing great.
- → Is chilling it necessary before eating?
It's even better after chilling for about an hour, but if you're in a rush, you can eat it right after mixing.
- → How long does this stay fresh?
Seal it in the fridge and it'll last for three days. Just give it a little stir each time you serve some.
- → What can I sprinkle on top?
Sprinkle a bit of paprika, slice up some green onions, or toss on fresh parsley for extra color and flavor.