Save Pin
Cheesy baked rigatoni is the hearty pasta dish everyone in my house begs for as soon as it gets chilly or party season hits. There are cozy layers of melty mozzarella, creamy ricotta, and bold tomato sauce loaded into every bite. I've whipped this up for everything—snowed-in weekends, birthday blowouts, you name it—and there’s never any left at the end.
Honestly, the first time I made this, the cheesy smell brought the whole crew running before it even finished baking. It’s earned a permanent spot in our holiday rotation.
Tasty Ingredients
- Rigatoni noodles: Go for ten ounces for the just-right sauce-to-pasta balance. DeCecco has great texture if you can find it.
- Olive oil (extra virgin): Gives the sauce a fruity boost. Choose a fresh bottle for the best taste.
- Vidalia or sweet onion: When sautéed, these onions almost melt. Pick one that's nice and firm with that crisp outer layer.
- Fresh garlic: Real cloves give amazing aroma. Look for bulbs that feel solid with tight skins—skip any with little green sprouts.
- Canned peeled tomatoes: Brings body and flavor to the sauce. If you spot San Marzano on the label, grab it—they’re sweet with less bite.
- Kosher salt: Brings out all the best flavors and helps balance the tang. Flaky is easier to sprinkle and dissolves right in.
- Black pepper: Freshly ground pepper wakes everything up.
- Garlic powder: Adds savory notes that hang around with the fresh garlic.
- Optional sugar: Use a pinch if the sauce feels too sharp—taste first so you don’t overdo it.
- Basil (fresh): Tear some in at the last minute for that bright finish. Leaves should be crisp and smell amazing.
- Ricotta (whole milk): So creamy and rich—use full-fat for best texture.
- Milk: Just a splash thins out the ricotta so it's easier to spread. Use whatever dairy milk is in your fridge.
- Egg (large): Holds everything together once baked.
- Romano or Parmesan (grated): For those sharp salty notes—Romano is tangier, Parmesan is classic.
- Mozzarella (shredded): Melts all stretchy and comfy. Part skim or whole milk—they both work fine.
- More grated cheese: For that golden bubbly top layer—don’t skip it!
Easy How-To Guide
- Bake Time:
- Cover your pan with parchment and then foil (really helps with cleanup). Pop it onto a foil-lined sheet if you're worried about spills. Give it thirty minutes at three hundred fifty degrees, covered. Take off the foil and let it go another fifteen to twenty. Once it’s bubbling and brown, you’re golden. Let it cool briefly so you don't burn your tongue when digging in.
- Layering Game:
- Spoon some sauce across the bottom of your baking dish. Toss in half the rigatoni, spread it even. Then dollop on half the ricotta mix and swirl it around—let it mix with the noodles a bit. Next comes half your mozzarella and a good sprinkle of cheese. Repeat with the rest. Finish with plenty of cheese for melt and crisp!
- Cheese Mix Prep:
- In a good-sized mixing bowl, blend the ricotta, milk, egg, and grated cheese with a fat pinch of salt and some fresh pepper. Stir until everything's creamy and smooth. That’s your cheesy filling for the layers.
- Pasta Boil:
- Get a big pot of salty water roaring. Drop in the noodles but pull them out halfway through the box’s time—they’ll cook more in the oven. Drain well, then mix them right away with a cup of your sauce so every piece picks up flavor.
- Sauce Cook:
- Pour in those tomatoes, mashing then up with a spoon. Let everything simmer for ten minutes to pull the flavors together. Drop in torn basil for a pop of freshness, then simmer again. Taste and tweak for seasoning—make sure it’s exactly how you like it.
- Start the Flavor:
- Heat up olive oil in a wide pan on medium. Cook chopped onions low and slow for about ten minutes, stirring now and then so they turn soft and clear but not brown. Stir in garlic next, cook for two more minutes until it smells awesome, and then add salt, pepper, garlic powder, and a pinch of sugar if you need it.
Save Pin
Good to Know
- Easily fills up six big appetites
- Freeze it unbaked or baked and have it ready for a busy night
- Doubles up without extra work if you’ve got a crowd
The moment I tear basil for the sauce, I remember my grandma’s kitchen. Tossing in handfuls of fresh basil and creamy ricotta to finish always takes me back. Every bite is cozy, like a hug from home.
Chill and Save
Let your pasta cool completely on the counter before putting it away. Wrap it up tight and stash in the fridge—you’ve got four days to enjoy leftovers. To warm up, add a splash of sauce or even water, then reheat covered in the oven. For freezing, stop before baking, seal it well, and freeze. When ready, let it thaw overnight in the fridge, then bake like usual. Tack on ten extra minutes for frozen ones.
Swaps & Mix-Ins
Can’t find rigatoni? Penne and ziti scoop up sauce and hold cheese just as well. Provolone will swap nicely for mozzarella if you want sharper flavor. If Romano’s gone, stick with Parmesan only. Want a twist? Try fire-roasted tomato sauce or sprinkle a bit of chili for gentle heat.
How to Serve
Spoon it hot from the oven with plenty of crisp salad and slices of soft bread for scooping up sauce. We like to plop extra ricotta or basil on top at the table. Crowd pleaser at potlucks—kids and grown-ups both go back for more.
Save Pin
Origins & Family Story
Cheesy baked pasta like this has roots in Italian-American kitchens, blending Italian roots with American-sized portions. Every family I know does it a little differently—someone always sneaks in their own favorite cheese or special sauce move for the holidays.
Common Questions
- → Is it okay to swap out rigatoni for something else?
Definitely! Penne or ziti are both great options and catch all that gooey cheese and sauce just like rigatoni does.
- → Why do I only need 10 ounces of pasta?
Using a little less lets this bake stay saucy and soft. The cheeses and sauce get to do their thing without the pasta drying everything out.
- → How should I put the cheeses in the dish?
Put a scoop of the ricotta on the pasta, then toss on mozzarella and Romano after that. Keep repeating for every cheesy layer, so it melts just right.
- → Should the pasta be fully cooked before it goes in the oven?
Nope. Boil it for about half the normal time. It’ll soak up sauce and finish cooking as it bakes, turning out nice and flavorful.
- → How do I keep the cheese from sticking to my foil?
Just lay some parchment or wax paper over the cheese before you cover with foil. That way you won’t lose any gooey topping.
- → Can the sauce be made ahead of time?
For sure. Make your sauce the day before and stash it in the fridge. If it’s cold, you’ll just want to give it a little extra bake time.