Save Pin
This family-favorite Southern pea salad brings together creamy, crunchy, and savory tastes that folks can't resist at potlucks or family dinners. Our clan's been whipping it up for as long as I can remember.
When I first made this for my hubby's family get-together, I was so worried about making a good impression. Later that day, his grandma quietly told me mine topped hers—there's no bigger win in Southern cooking than that! I knew right then I was truly part of the family.
Ingredients
- Frozen sweet peas: Make sure they're totally thawed so your salad stays bright and doesn't get watery
- Hard boiled eggs: They make this side heartier and add a nice rich touch
- Bacon: Cook it till it's nice and crispy to add that smoky goodness that makes everything better
- Green onions: They're gentler than regular onions so they don't take over the delicate pea flavor
- Shredded cheddar cheese: Gives you tasty little pockets of cheesy flavor in every bite
- Black pepper: Try to grind it fresh for the tastiest results
- Salt: Brings out the goodness in all the other stuff
- Garlic powder: Adds nice background flavor without the sharpness of fresh garlic
- Celery seeds: Gives that authentic down-home taste without actual celery chunks
- Cayenne pepper: Just a tiny bit perks up the whole dish without making it hot
- Mayonnaise: Grab the good stuff for the smoothest, creamiest result
- Sour cream: Adds a nice tang that cuts through the richness of the mayo
Step-by-Step Instructions
- Marry The Flavors:
- After you've mixed everything else, pour your dressing over the pea mixture and stir it in gently so you don't squish the peas. Wrap the bowl tight with plastic and let it chill for at least an hour, but leaving it overnight works even better—all those flavors get friendly with each other and the dressing firms up just right.
- Create The Dressing:
- Mix your mayo and sour cream in a separate bowl until they're completely blended with no streaks. This extra little step means your dressing will coat everything evenly instead of having some bites that are just mayo and others that are just sour cream. It's that perfect mix of rich and tangy.
- Season Thoughtfully:
- Sprinkle all your seasonings over everything, going easy on the cayenne unless you like things spicy. That mix of pepper, salt, garlic powder and celery seeds is what gives it that unmistakable Southern taste. Make sure you stir real good after adding the seasonings so they spread out evenly.
- Combine Base Ingredients:
- Start with your thawed peas in the mixing bowl, making sure they're good and drained so your salad isn't swimming. Next, gently add your chopped eggs—don't mix too hard or you'll mash them up. You want those pretty yellow and white bits showing. Scatter your bacon pieces all through the mixture, then toss in your green onions and cheese, mixing lightly so the peas stay whole.
Save Pin
Those celery seeds are what makes this recipe special. My grandma always skipped the fresh celery and went straight for the seeds. She'd say they pack all the flavor without messing up the smooth texture. I still keep a jar just for this dish, and whenever I open it, that smell takes me right back to her kitchen.
Storage Tips
You can keep this pea salad in the fridge for about three days if you use a container with a good seal. The funny thing is, it actually tastes better the next day when all the flavors have had time to mix and mingle. I usually make a big batch on weekends so we can snack on it for a few days. Just give it a quick stir before you serve it if you notice any liquid has separated.
Clever Variations
Bacon might be the classic choice for Southern pea salad, but everyone's got their own spin on it. My mother-in-law won't use anything but diced ham—she thinks it's less smoky and more savory. You could throw in some chopped bell peppers for extra crunch and color, or swap out the cheddar for Monterey Jack if you want something milder. I've even seen recipes in our church cookbook that call for a spoonful of sweet pickle relish, which adds a nice little sweet kick against all those savory ingredients.
Save Pin
Serving Suggestions
This salad goes with just about anything Southern—fried chicken, country ham, or BBQ ribs. In summertime, we serve it cold alongside spicy grilled stuff. At holiday dinners, it adds some nice green to the table and gives folks a lighter option among all those heavy sides. It also looks really pretty if you scoop it into lettuce cups for fancy gatherings.
Cultural Significance
Pea salad runs deep in Southern cooking, going back to when folks relied on things they could store in cans and jars. You can find fancy versions in restaurants nowadays, but this down-home recipe is what you'll see at church potlucks and family gatherings all across the South. My husband's family wouldn't dream of having Easter or Fourth of July without it. The recipe's stayed pretty much the same for at least four generations.
Common Questions
- → Can I swap frozen peas for canned ones?
Absolutely, canned peas work fine too. Just drain and rinse them well before adding them in.
- → What's a good bacon substitute?
Diced ham works wonderfully, or just leave it out completely if you want a meat-free option.
- → What's the best way to serve this dish?
Serve it cold from the fridge - it makes a fantastic side for cookouts, community dinners, or regular family meals.
- → Can I mix this up a day early?
You can definitely make it the day before. Keep it in the fridge to let all the flavors soak together.
- → Which cheese tastes best in this mix?
Most folks love sharp cheddar, but feel free to try whatever cheese you enjoy most.