Save Pin
These cucumber sandwiches are a timeless tea party staple, perfect for outdoor celebrations, wedding showers, or when you're craving a light, cool snack. The mix of crisp cucumbers and herb-infused cream cheese creates a tasty balance that's both down-to-earth and fancy at once.
I first threw these cucumber sandwiches together for my little girl's tea party birthday, and they were such a crowd-pleaser that we now make them for all our summer hangouts. There's something really classy about how simple they are.
Ingredients
- Cream cheese: gives you that smooth foundation that brings it all together - go with full-fat for the best taste
- Mayonnaise: makes everything creamy and easy to spread
- Fresh dill: adds that fresh, aromatic kick that works so well with cucumber
- Fresh chives: brings a subtle onion flavor without taking over
- Garlic powder: just a touch for extra flavor without standing out too much
- Salt and pepper: key for making all the flavors pop
- English cucumber: fewer seeds and thinner skin compared to regular ones
- White bread: the classic pick for tea sandwiches but any soft bread will do the trick
Easy Preparation Steps
- Mix Your Spread:
- Whip the room-temperature cream cheese and mayo with a mixer until it's light and smooth. This should take roughly 2 minutes. Make sure your cream cheese isn't cold or you'll end up with chunks in your spread.
- Mix In Seasonings:
- Stir in your chopped dill, chives, garlic powder, salt, and pepper. Give it a taste and add more if needed. You want those herbs mixed through the whole batch.
- Get Your Bread Ready:
- Cut the crusts off your bread if you want. This makes them look more fancy and delicate for tea time. Put them aside for now.
- Cut Your Cucumber:
- Slice the English cucumber super thin, almost see-through. A mandoline works wonders here, but a sharp knife works fine too. Pat the slices with paper towels to get rid of extra water.
- Start Building:
- Spread your cream cheese mix evenly across one side of each bread slice. Don't be stingy this is where all the good taste comes from.
- Add Cucumbers:
- Place cucumber slices so they slightly overlap on half of your bread slices. Sprinkle with extra fresh herbs if you want them to look extra pretty.
- Finish Them Off:
- Put the remaining bread on top, cream cheese side facing down. Press lightly to hold everything together.
- Slice and Enjoy:
- With a sharp knife, cut each sandwich into three even strips or triangles if you like. Wipe your knife between cuts to keep the edges nice and clean.
Save Pin
What makes these sandwiches special is the herb combo. While dill is the classic choice, I once had to swap in basil when my dill plant died, and it made a totally different but equally yummy version that my family now asks for all the time.
Keeping Your Sandwiches Fresh
You can make these cucumber treats up to a day ahead, which is great when you're planning a party. Keep them in a sealed container with a slightly wet paper towel on top so the bread stays soft. Wrap the whole thing in plastic for extra protection. Just remember to keep them cool without letting them get too damp and soggy.
Tasty Twists
The original recipe is wonderful, but there are lots of ways to switch things up. Try adding thin radish slices for some spicy crunch, or mix lemon zest into your cream cheese for a fresh zing. Want something more filling? Tuck some smoked salmon between the cucumber and cream cheese. Watercress or microgreens also look pretty and add extra nutrients.
Save Pin
Pairing Ideas
Cucumber sandwiches usually show up at afternoon tea with scones and little desserts. They work great as finger food at baby showers or wedding parties when cut smaller. Drink-wise, they go well with cold tea in summer or hot tea when it's chilly. For a simple lunch, serve them alongside a basic soup like tomato or carrot.
History Behind The Bites
These little sandwiches have been part of British tea time since Victorian days. They used to show off wealth since cucumbers weren't cheap back then. Now they stand for good taste and tradition while still fitting perfectly into today's parties and gatherings.
Common Questions
- → What type of bread works best for cucumber sandwiches?
Traditional options include soft white bread, but don't shy away from trying whole grain, rye, or even pumpernickel for extra flavor and heartiness.
- → Can I prepare the sandwiches ahead of time?
You can make them up to 24 hours before serving if you keep them wrapped up in the fridge to stay fresh.
- → What herbs can I use for the cream cheese spread?
While fresh dill and chives work wonderfully, try swapping in parsley, basil, or cilantro when you want a different taste.
- → How can I thinly slice cucumbers easily?
A mandoline makes quick work of getting even, thin slices, but a good sharp knife works too if you take your time.
- → Can I make these sandwiches gluten-free?
They're super easy to adapt. Just swap in your favorite gluten-free bread and you're all set for a tasty gluten-free option.