Save Pin
Every Memorial Day, folks ask me to bring my go-to pasta dish because it's the star of the BBQ. It comes together quick, gives you a crunch of fresh veggies in every bite, and that zippy dressing totally makes it. Bright colors mean it looks as awesome as it tastes. Bring it to the park or party—just let it chill in your fridge for extra flavor.
My kids beg for this when birthdays roll around, and neighbors hope I'll drop by with a batch when summer gets hot. My favorite part is when someone takes their first mouthful and immediately asks how to put it together.
Tasty Ingredients
- Red wine vinegar: Gives a little zing and helps the dressing stick to the noodles
- Cherry tomatoes: Choose plump ones for juicy, sweet bites—they really brighten things up
- Rotini or bowtie pasta: Cool twisty shapes like these really grab onto dressing and veggies—cook until they’re still a bit springy
- Cheddar or mozzarella cheese: Cube these up for creamy pops in every scoop, or toss in mozzarella pearls for fun
- Garlic powder: Adds mellow garlic flavor to every mouthful—fresh jar is best for big taste
- Black olives: Sliced and briny—drain ’em so they hold their texture
- Red onion: Dice it tiny for a smack of sharpness—if it’s harsh, soak in iced water to mellow
- Red bell pepper: Sweet, crisp, and adds a pop of color—pick a firm, shiny one for max flavor
- Dijon mustard: Lends a tang that just ties everything together
- Fresh parsley or basil: Chop fine for a fresh burst of green—healthy leaves taste brightest
- Salami or pepperoni: Want it a little heartier? Thin slices blend right in, or skip them for a plant version
- Salt and pepper: Round out the whole mix—taste as you go
- Cucumber: Tons of crunch—English or Persian varieties won’t water down your bowl
- Italian dressing: Use whatever bottle you love, or whisk up your own—just be sure it’s got olive oil and some tang
Simple How-To
- Boil the Pasta:
- Cook pasta in salty water, just until it’s got a little bite left, and then rinse it cold so it doesn’t get sticky. Drain well so it doesn’t get mushy.
- Chop Veggies and Cheese:
- Slice your veggies, cheese, and meat (if using) into small pieces. Smaller bits make sure every spoonful gets a little of everything.
- Make the Dressing:
- Whisk together mustard, Italian dressing, garlic powder, red wine vinegar, and seasoning. Taste and fix anything you want.
- Mix It All Up:
- Toss cooled pasta with veggies, cheese, herbs, meat if you’re using, and pour on the dressing. Mix really well so everything’s coated.
- Chill the Salad:
- Cover and refrigerate for at least one hour or overnight, so the flavors meld. Stir before serving and add more dressing or salt if needed.
Save Pin
Truthfully, I have a real soft spot for fresh basil in this. The smell is pure summer and always makes me think of grandma’s backyard garden. Last year, my youngest picked every cherry tomato for our big family dinner—it made it extra special that night!
Storing Tips
Want to prep ahead? Pop it in a sealed container—it’ll be happy in the fridge up to three days. If it dries out, just drizzle on a bit more Italian dressing before eating. Outdoors, make sure it doesn’t sit out over two hours.
Swap Suggestions
Penne or fusilli work great if you’re out of rotini. Ditch the meat for a veggie-friendly option, or pile in vegan cheese and extra herbs to go all plant-based. Gluten-free noodles are awesome here—just watch so they stay firm.
Save Pin
Creative Ways to Serve
Ladle it in a bright dish and top with a flurry of basil. Try it next to burgers, grilled chicken, or put it on a veggie spread. Add sunflower seeds or extra bell pepper for extra crunch. Got leftovers? Scoop some with pita chips for a speedy lunch.
The Story Behind the Dish
This pasta salad took off in the states after World War II, thanks to busy potlucks and summer hangouts. Twisty pastas like rotini meant you could toss in leftovers or any veggie you had, and it worked for feeding a crowd anytime. Every family plays around with their own style—ours leans Mediterranean, and people always want seconds.
Common Questions
- → How early can I make the salad?
Totally fine to make it the day before! It actually gets even yummier after chilling. Just give it a quick mix right before serving, and pour on more dressing if it needs it.
- → What pasta shape works best?
Try short, chunky kinds like rotini or bowties. They trap all the tasty bits. Any gluten-free pasta swaps in great, too.
- → Want it all veggie?
Skip anything like salami. It tastes awesome just with veggies and cheese—or add chickpeas for a little extra protein.
- → How do I keep it moist?
If you notice the salad looking a little dry, just splash on more dressing and mix. Super handy if you made it ahead.
- → Are cheese swaps okay?
Mozzarella and cheddar are both tasty, but you can totally use feta, provolone, or try dairy-free cheese if you like a change.
- → Can I add different veggies?
Absolutely! Chopped spinach, sun-dried tomatoes, artichoke, or broccoli all bring more flavor and color to the bowl.