Save Pin
The first time I made Hawaiian Roll French Toast, it was early on a lazy Sunday morning, sun streaming in, with the scent of sweet bread wafting from the bag. My sister and I had found ourselves with half a package of King’s Hawaiian rolls leftover from dinner, and neither of us wanted another turkey sandwich. One impulsive flip through the fridge later—eggs, milk, a nub of butter—and our quiet breakfast turned into an event. The way those pillowy rolls soaked in the custard and crisped up, with the flavors of vanilla and cinnamon wrapping around the golden crust, was pure comfort on a fork.
My introduction to this twist came out of curiosity (read: desperation to avoid another boring breakfast). I’ll never go back to regular sandwich bread again. It’s the kind of recipe that sneaks its way into your weekend routine—effortless, a little indulgent, and delightfully nostalgic of bakery mornings.
Essential Ingredients
- King’s Hawaiian rolls: The backbone of this dish: plush, lightly sweet, and uniquely tender. Grab the original sweet rolls, ideally a day or two old so they can soak without falling apart. The telltale orangey-gold hue and soft touch mean you’ve found a fresh batch.
- Eggs (4 large): The custard-maker. Look for firm, uncracked shells; deep yellow yolks mean rich flavor.
- Milk (1 cup): Whole milk delivers maximum creaminess, but 2% or even oat milk will work. Fresh milk smells subtly sweet, never sour; check dates and shake well.
- Vanilla extract (1 tsp): Legit vanilla extract, not imitation, is worth every penny. It brings warmth and depth.
- Cinnamon (¼ tsp): Ground cinnamon adds cozy spice. Choose brands with a robust aroma and a warm color. Adventurous? Add nutmeg or cardamom for a twist.
- Pinch of salt: Essential for balancing and intensifying all the flavors. Kosher or fine sea salt dissolves best.
- Butter for cooking: Nothing beats real butter for that nutty-browned finish. Unsalted lets you control the seasoning, but use what you have.
- Maple syrup for serving: Go for pure maple syrup. Its earthy sweetness brings everything together. Grade A amber is the go-to for most palates.
Cooking Process
- Soak the Rolls:
- Whisk eggs, milk, vanilla, cinnamon, and salt until smooth and streak-free. This custard needs to be well-mixed so every inch of bread absorbs uniform flavor.
- Dunk, Don’t Drown:
- Slice the rolls in half (if you like them individually browned, or leave attached for a “pull-apart” effect). Quickly dip each side into the custard—about 10 seconds per side. This allows for a tender middle without sogginess. Rushed dunks won’t infuse flavor; long soaks make for mush.
- Brown in Butter:
- Preheat a skillet or griddle over medium-low heat. Drop in butter and let it foam; this ensures even browning. Place the soaked rolls cut-side down, spacing them apart for a crisp finish, and cook 2–3 minutes per side until deeply golden. Resist moving them too soon—proper caramelization takes patience and rewards you with a delicate crust.
- Serve Generously:
- Stack the French toast on plates, shower with more butter, and drizzle maple syrup. Each bite should be warm, soft in the middle, and just crisp enough on the edges.
Save Pin
Recipe Highlights
Delivers 380–450 calories per serving—hearty and satisfying for breakfast or brunch
A clever way to rescue day-old bread and save money
No fancy techniques; kid-friendly and nearly foolproof
One of my favorite variations is to stuff the split rolls with a swipe of sweetened cream cheese and a handful of berries before dunking. The first time I tried it, I overfilled and lost a rogue blueberry to the frying pan; ten minutes later, victory was snacking on the “mistake” over the sink while the rest finished crisping.
Make-ahead Strategies
French toast is surprisingly freezer-friendly. Assemble and cook as usual, let cool, then freeze flat in a single layer. Reheat in a toaster oven or oven for instant brunch—no soggy microwaved slices here.
Flavor Variations
Swap cinnamon for cardamom and orange zest for a fragrant holiday version. Feeling tropical? Garnish with toasted coconut and a drizzle of passionfruit syrup. For a dessert spin, roll the cooked pieces in cinnamon sugar (hello, French toast “churros”).
Save Pin
Seasonal Adaptations
In fall, add a spoonful of pumpkin puree and pinch of pumpkin spice to the custard. Late summer? Sliced fresh peaches sandwiched in the rolls before dunking are pure bliss.
Kitchen Tool Recommendations
A broad nonstick or cast-iron skillet makes flipping a breeze. If you’re cooking for a crowd, a large griddle speeds things up and keeps slices equally browned. A wide shallow bowl guarantees every roll gets an even bath in the custard.
Cooking Secrets
Slightly stale rolls are non-negotiable: fresh bread turns soggy, but 1–2 day-old rolls hold their own beautifully.
Let the custard cling: after dunking, hold the rolls above the bowl for a couple seconds to drain excess—this helps set the perfect custardy texture.
Medium-low heat is your friend. Butter burns fast, and too-high heat leaves you with burnt outsides and raw middles. A patient slow sizzle means golden, custardy French toast every single batch.
After dozens of weekends tinkering and “sampling,” this is still the French toast recipe that never lasts more than a few minutes once served. It’s easy, cozy, and practically guaranteed to prompt a “Can you make it again next week?”
Common Questions
- → Why use King’s Hawaiian rolls for French toast?
Their soft, sweet texture and subtle pineapple notes create an especially tender, flavorful toast compared to standard bread.
- → Can stale Hawaiian rolls be used?
Slightly stale rolls are perfect as they absorb the custard well without becoming mushy, yielding a better texture.
- → What milk type works best?
Whole milk gives the richest result, but you can use 2%, half-and-half, or non-dairy alternatives like almond milk if needed.
- → Is it essential to use pure vanilla extract?
Pure vanilla brings deeper, more complex flavor, but imitation can be used in a pinch with a slight loss of aroma.
- → How should the rolls be cooked?
Fry in butter over medium heat until golden-brown and crisp on both sides. Butter enhances flavor and browning.
- → What can I serve with this dish?
Drizzle with maple syrup, fresh berries, or a dusting of powdered sugar for a classic breakfast or brunch finish.