Save Pin
This one-pan wonder packs everything I crave from a warm family supper: crispy beef bacon, juicy bites of chicken, a shower of gooey cheese, and soft cubes of buttery potato. What was once a fun way to clear out the fridge is now our absolute must-make anytime we want a feel-good crowd-pleaser.
I can't make this without it disappearing at parties. My husband even begs for it come football weekends.
Tempting Ingredients
- Russet potatoes: choose big, smooth ones, bake then chill, and slice them up for the best creamy bites
- Rotisserie chicken: tearing up a fresh one keeps things juicy and saves you loads of time
- Full fat sour cream: gets you that deep tang and creamy punch in every forkful
- Sharp cheddar cheese: grate your own if you can—bolder taste and melts way better
- Fresh green onions: the crisp, bright green tops give a little zip and color kick
- Real beef bacon bits: go for the real stuff so you get the crunch and real meaty flavor
- Salt and black pepper: flaky salt and fresh peppercorns really lift the flavors
- Whole milk: full-fat milk means the sauce gets dreamy and rich
Ridiculously Good Steps
- Bake and Dice Potatoes:
- Pop your russets in the oven, cool 'em off, chop into big cubes for that creamy, chunky base.
- Spread Potatoes:
- Scoop half the chunks into a greased 9x13 pan and smooth them out, making a soft bed for everything else.
- Add Chicken:
- Drop on half your chicken, then press down any extra-large pieces so things stay even.
- Mix Cream Sauce:
- Whisk together whole milk and sour cream till it’s all blended, then pour half of that silky sauce across the top.
- Get Topping:
- Top it with half the cheddar, green onions, and your crunchy beef bacon bits. Sprinkle with salt and pepper for that final bump of flavor.
- Build the Last Layers:
- Layer on everything that’s left: more potatoes, chicken, cheesy sauce, those onions, and bacon. Stack it up for bigger flavor.
- Bake Covered:
- Wrap your dish snug in foil, and bake at 350°F for 35–40 minutes so everything bubbles and gets hot inside.
- Let It Get Crispy:
- Take off the foil, bake another 5–10 minutes till golden and bubbling. Let it chill five minutes before digging in.
Save Pin
As soon as the bacon and cheese aromas start wafting from the oven, my kid zooms in asking for a big corner piece with extra golden potatoes. He's all about those toasty edges.
Simple Storage Tricks
Let it cool all the way before stashing it away. Once it's room temp, slice it up and pack into containers with lids—stick in the fridge for three days max. If you need to save longer, wrap up single servings and freeze for up to two months. Warm it in the oven on low so everything stays melty.
Swaps That Work
Try sweet potatoes if you want a sweeter dish. Out of beef bacon? Turkey or pork bacon will hit the spot. For more veggies, toss in cooked corn or broccoli with your chicken. Swap the cheddar for Monterey Jack or Gruyère if you want to play with the cheese flavors.
Tasty Serving Ideas
Serve this with a super crisp lettuce salad to balance out the creamy goodness. A scoop of sour cream or dash of hot sauce makes every bite pop. Roasted green beans or steamed broccoli are also solid picks for the side. We like to finish dinner with fresh, crunchy apples to keep things bright and light.
Save Pin
Why This Comfort Classic Stuck Around
It brings together everything people crave from that iconic steakhouse vibe: cheese, bacon, potatoes, sour cream, all spun out of old Midwest staples. Adding chicken shifts it from a side to the main event, so it's both filling and practical. Dishes like this have been a lifesaver for busy families for years—turning kitchen basics into something really satisfying.
Common Questions
- → What’s the trick to making sure my potatoes are totally soft?
Bake the russets until you can poke a fork straight through before slicing them up. This gives you fluffy potatoes in every bite.
- → Can I sub in just regular cooked chicken breast for rotisserie style?
Absolutely. Just shred up some cooked chicken breast or thighs—works like a charm and still tastes amazing.
- → How do I make the cheese and bacon on top nice and browned?
Take off the foil for the last 5–10 minutes in the oven. That’ll let those cheesy bits and bacon really crisp up.
- → Can I swap cheeses for something new?
Sharp cheddar gives you a solid flavor, but Monterey Jack or even Gouda brings a fun change if you’re up for it.
- → Got advice for keeping leftovers tasty and fresh?
Once it cools, wrap it tightly and store in the fridge up to three days. Reheat slowly to keep it from drying out.
- → Is it possible to prep it all ahead?
You bet. Put it all together the night before and chill, then just bake whenever you’re ready to eat for top-notch texture.